What about vaginal extraction of the kidney? results of an online survey

Posted | Comments Off on What about vaginal extraction of the kidney? results of an online survey

Vol. 42 (1): 78-82, January – February, 2016

doi: 10.1590/S1677-5538.IBJU.2015.0170


What about vaginal extraction of the kidney? results of an online survey

Joao Ferreira Cabral 1, Isaac Campos Braga 1, 2, Frederico Branco 1, Vitor Cavadas 1, Avelino Fraga Ferreira 1,3, Miguel Silva Ramos 1
1 Departamento de Urologia, Hospital de Santo António – C.H.P, Porto, Portugal; 2 Instituto de Investigação em Ciências da Vida e da Saúde – I.C.V.S, Universidade do Minho; ICVS/3B´s – PT Laboratório Associado ao Governo, Braga, Portugal; 3 Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas Abel Salazar – I.C.B.A.S – Universidade do Porto, Porto, Portugal


Purpose: We aimed to characterize surgeons opinion about the vaginal extraction of the kidney after transperitoneal laparoscopic nephrectomy. Matherial and Methods: A 9-item questionnaire was published online (Survey Monkey TM) and publicized via email to a multidisciplinary pool of surgeons in Portugal.
Data was collected and statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS Statistics, Version 21.0.
Results: Three hundred and fifty nine inquiries were sent, 154 surgeons completed the questionnaires (response rate of 43.0%). Fifty five point eight percent of the participants would choose the transvaginal approach for themselves or for a close relative. The most stated arguments were a better cosmesis (29.0%) expectancy of lower post operative pain (26.0%) and lower rate of incisional hernias (23.0%). Defenders of the transabdominal procedure justified with an expectancy of lower complication rate (39%), namely impairment of sexual function and fertility (22%). The female gender and the familiarity with transvaginal surgery were the stronger predictors of the option for this approach (70.6% vs 48.5%; p=0,016 and 85.3% vs 46.6%; p <0.001 respectively).
Conclusions: Contrasting with similar surveys published on transvaginal NOTES, the vaginal specimen extraction after conventional laparoscopic nephrectomy was fairly accepted by the inquired surgeons.

Keywords: Endoscopy; Kidney; Vagina

[Full Text]